Chapter 3: Eighteen Months

A young woman holding a tablet at a banquet table while her aunt sits beside her and her mother leans over the table

“You were still at the rehabilitation center,” I said.

Nora nodded.

“Did anybody take you outside for appointments?”

Her tablet answered.

“No.”

Dana shifted her bag.

“There are arrangements that start before discharge.”

“Was that what this was?”

“I’d need to check the dates.”

“They’re on the statement.”

Paul held out a hand.

“Let’s make sure we’re comparing the right things.”

Nora opened her calendar beside the oldest payment.

A discharge date appeared farther down.

Her finger moved between them.

I remembered visiting that room.

The cane had still been new.

“I was there,” I said.

“Yes,” her tablet answered.

Leah brought the calculator up on her phone.

“Eighteen times twenty-seven hundred?”

Nora shook her head.

“Wait,” her tablet said.

Dana leaned forward.

“Exactly. You can’t just add everything.”

Nora tapped her speaker.

“Not everything. Only Briar.”

She pointed at a pharmacy payment.

“This was real,” the tablet said.

Then a therapy bill.

“This was real, too.”

I turned the invoice sideways.

“So those stay separate.”

“Yes,” her tablet answered.

Dana’s mouth tightened.

“Nobody said the others weren’t real.”

“She’s being careful,” I said.

Paul nodded.

“That’s what we need. Careful.”

Nora touched Briar’s entry again.

“These are different.”

Silence.

“Are all eighteen Briar payments completed?”

Nora’s tablet answered.

“Yes.”

“Any refunds?”

“No.”

Leah checked each date against her list.

“I’ve got eighteen.”

“Read me the amounts.”

“They’re all the same.”

Dana rubbed her forehead.

“This isn’t the time to calculate a worst possible interpretation.”

“It’s the time to calculate what left her account.”

Leah turned her phone toward me.

$48,600.

“Forty-eight thousand six hundred dollars. That left Nora’s own account.”

Dana looked away.

“Nora needed help.”

“She still needs help,” I said.

“She needs an answer.”

Paul moved his chair closer.

“We’ll get one.”

“From whom?”

Nobody answered immediately.

Dana pulled her chair toward the table.

“You’re making it sound as though I spent her money on myself.”

“Tell us what you spent it on.”

“I’ve told you.”

“Transport.”

“Support.”

“Those aren’t the same answer.”

“Support includes transport.”

“For eighteen months?”

“There’s been a lot to manage.”

Nora pressed the speech button.

“I know. It happened to me.”

Dana blinked.

“That’s not what I meant.”

“Then what did you mean?”

Paul touched Dana’s shoulder.

“Let her explain.”

I waited.

My sister stared at the invoice.

Leah’s phone went dark beside it.

Nobody reached to wake the screen.

“Well?”

Nothing.

Nora opened the receipt for March twelfth.

“This was my last paid ride,” her tablet said.

“The real one?” I asked.

“Yes.”

“This has a pickup, a destination, and the name of her driver.”

Leah put it beside the Briar invoice.

“This one says where she went.”

“Different companies use different forms,” Dana said.

“Different forms still describe a service.”

“Beth, I’m not responsible for their formatting.”

“Are you responsible for checking the bill?”

Dana’s fingers closed on her bag.

“Of course.”

“Then what did you check?”

Nora’s tablet spoke.

“I asked that, too.”

Paul lifted his chin.

“When, kiddo?”

“Last week,” Nora’s tablet answered.

Dana shook her head.

“She asked for bank statements. That’s different from asking me to explain a provider’s invoices.”

“Both concern her money,” I said.

“I’ve been handling it because someone had to.”

“Someone she authorized?”

“Yes.”

“May we see that authorization?”

Dana opened a folder inside her bag.

“I brought it because I knew how this would look.”

Paul’s hand left her shoulder.

“You expected questions?” I asked.

“She’s been questioning everything.”

Nora’s tablet answered.

“Because nothing matches.”

Dana laid a document down.

“There. My authority.”

Nora tapped the speech button.

“I’ll read it.”

“Do you want me to read with you?”

Nora nodded.

Dana pointed near the bottom.

“Her signature. She asked me to help.”

“We’ll start at the top,” I said.

Nora turned the page flat.

Limited financial authorization.

“It says limited.”

“It covers what she needed,” Dana said.

“Paying legitimate bills and expenses on her behalf.”

“Exactly.”

“Keeping records of those payments.”

“I keep records.”

“Making them available to her.”

“Which is what we’re doing.”

Nora’s tablet spoke.

“You didn’t give them to me.”

“I was going to.”

“When?”

“Once I’d explained them.”

Paul leaned forward.

“Let’s finish reading first.”

“Yes.”

“What does the next section say?”

Nora followed the lines with her finger.

“Expenses for my benefit,” her tablet read.

Dana spread her hands.

“Everything I did was for her benefit.”

“Does it authorize payments for services she didn’t receive?”

“You keep assuming that.”

“We’re checking it.”

“It doesn’t list every possible expense.”

“Does it say you can use her money however you choose?”

“No, and I haven’t.”

Paul spoke carefully.

“Beth, an authorization isn’t a receipt. We still need to understand the payments.”

“I agree.”

Dana tapped Nora’s signature.

“But she signed.”

Nora covered the page’s corner.

“Not everything.”

“I signed so Mom could pay my bills,” Nora’s tablet said.

“Not so I’d stop seeing them.”

“I never said that,” Dana answered.

I read the authorization again.

There was no permission to fund anyone else.

“Did you keep copies?” I asked.

“Yes,” Dana said.

“May Nora have them?”

“She already has the statements.”

“The bills and invoices.”

“They’re at home.”

“All of them?”

“I’d need to check.”

Paul looked at Nora.

“We can gather everything.”

“When?” her tablet asked.

“Tomorrow.”

“Why wasn’t it given to her already?”

Dana lifted the authorization.

“Because she needed time.”

“To do what?”

Silence.

Nora drew the authorization back.

“To recover,” Dana said.

“My speech,” Nora’s tablet answered.

“Lots of things.”

“My hand,” the tablet said.

“Nora, please.”

“Not my right to ask.”

I looked down before my sister could answer.

Nora had opened another folder.

Rehabilitation.

“Do you want us to look at this?”

“Yes,” her tablet said.

“Only what you need us to see.”

She selected a dated discharge summary.

I kept my eyes on the dates.

They bracketed the first transport charge.

Dana leaned closer.

“That doesn’t explain the billing.”

“It explains where she was.”

Paul held still.

“Show us more.”

Nora pointed to the section listing outside appointments.

None during that period.

“We didn’t leave,” her tablet said.

Dana shook her head.

“You left the building.”

“For the courtyard,” the tablet answered.

Leah looked at the invoice.

“Was somebody charging to drive her into the courtyard?”

“Don’t be ridiculous.”

“Then what outside transport did she receive?”

Dana pushed back from the table.

“Preparations. A service arranged before she came home.”

“That’s not what the invoice says,” I answered.

“It says passenger transport.”

“That includes arrangements.”

“Show us those arrangements.”

“They wouldn’t be in medical records.”

“Then show us yours.”

Nothing.

Nora opened the invoice covering June eighteenth.

Then her appointment record.

“It says you didn’t attend that day.”

“No ride,” her tablet said.

Dana reached for her phone.

“Sometimes appointments change.”

“Not this one,” I said.

“We saw the message.”

“A message isn’t the whole story.”

“The appointment record says she didn’t attend.”

“Exactly.”

“And her messages say she couldn’t get there.”

Paul leaned back.

“We need to ask the provider.”

“Please do,” I said.

Dana’s phone remained black.

“Are you calling?” Leah asked.

“I don’t have the number here.”

“The invoice?”

“It isn’t on it.”

Leah unfolded it completely.

Nora rubbed her left wrist.

I moved the tablet closer.

“Would you like a break?”

Dana started to stand.

“Yes, she needs one.”

“I’m asking Nora.”

Paul nodded toward the hall.

“We could all use a few minutes.”

Nora pressed her speech button.

“Water. Not a break.”

Leah took the empty glass.

“I’ll get it.”

Dana caught her sleeve.

“And tell Tessa we’re coming back.”

Leah looked at Nora.

“Are we?”

“Not yet,” Nora’s tablet answered.

Dana let go.

I recognized the difference between being tired and being finished.

I’d mistaken it before.

Paul checked the doorway.

“We’ll wait here.”

“Do you remember the ramp application?” I asked Nora.

She nodded.

Dana frowned.

“What does that have to do with transport?”

“Eight months ago. Nora signed it herself.”

“She’d been practicing,” Dana said.

“I remember.”

I’d sat across from Nora while she steadied the paper.

She had refused my offer to write for her.

“You wanted every letter right.”

“Yes,” her tablet answered.

“You checked the measurements, too.”

Dana waved a hand.

“She could understand a ramp.”

I looked at my sister.

“What does that mean?”

“Don’t turn it into something.”

“Then finish the thought.”

Paul shifted closer.

“Dana, careful.”

Dana turned the authorization toward herself.

“I mean some decisions are easier than others. Measuring a doorway isn’t the same as understanding ongoing expenses.”

Nora’s tablet spoke.

“Then explain the expenses.”

“I’ve tried.”

“Try without saying I’m confused,” the tablet said.

“Nobody said confused,” Paul answered.

Dana nodded.

“Exactly.”

I pointed to the invoice.

“She understands dates. She understands money leaving her account. She understands whether somebody picked her up.”

“She doesn’t see everything I do.”

“Then let her see it.”

Dana folded the authorization.

“I’m not being thanked for any of it.”

Nora’s tablet answered.

“I only want answers.”

I remembered that ramp form folded beneath Nora’s hand.

The slow letters. The care she took before signing.

I’d called it progress.

Then I’d let Dana answer questions meant for her.

“Nora, did you want help paying bills?”

Her tablet answered.

“Yes.”

“Did you want to stop deciding what to pay?”

“No.”

Dana exhaled.

“That isn’t what happened.”

“What happened, then?”

“She was recovering.”

“She still is.”

“And I still have responsibilities.”

Paul looked between us.

“We all do.”

“Then help her get the records.”

“I said I would.”

“Tonight?”

“Let’s be practical.”

Nora’s tablet spoke.

“Practical for whom?”

Nobody answered.

Leah returned with water.

“The Whitakers are leaving,” she said.

“They asked whether you’re coming.”

Paul stood.

“Of course. I should thank them.”

Dana reached for her bag.

“I’ll come.”

Nora’s tablet spoke.

“Please leave the papers.”

Dana paused.

“They’re my copies.”

“They concern her money,” I said.

“I’m not going to hide them.”

“Then leave them.”

Paul touched Dana’s elbow.

“Let’s give Beth a chance to read.”

My sister set the folder down.

Leah’s phone lit up.

A message preview appeared.

She looked at us both.

“What is it?”

“The seating instructions.”

Dana stopped at the door.

“Delete those.”

“Why?” Leah asked.

“They’re private.”

“You asked me to arrange it.”

“I asked you to consider her needs.”

Leah turned the phone toward Nora.

“May I read it?”

Nora nodded.

“Put Nora near the kitchen. Somewhere she can sit separately if her tablet gets distracting.”

Dana glanced into the hall.

“That was a suggestion.”

“You didn’t say to ask her.”

“I assumed you would.”

“I should have,” Leah said.

She faced her cousin.

“I’m sorry. I thought your mom knew what you wanted.”

Nora pressed her tablet’s button.

“You know now.”

Leah nodded.

Dana’s hand tightened on the doorframe.

“Enough, Leah.”

Paul returned before Dana moved.

“Everything all right?”

“She’s reading private messages,” Dana said.

“About Nora,” Leah answered.

“Let’s slow down.”

“We’ve been sitting here,” I said.

“I mean how we’re speaking to each other.”

Nora looked at the papers.

Dana slid her phone into her bag.

Paul rested his palms on the table.

“Nobody wants Nora excluded. Nobody wants her money mishandled. We need to understand what happened before we decide anybody meant harm.”

“I’m asking for that understanding.”

“Then let Dana gather the records.”

Nora’s tablet answered.

“I’ve been asking her.”

Paul nodded.

“We’ve heard you, kiddo.”

“Finally.”

“Eighteen months,” Nora’s tablet said.

Dana shook her head.

“Don’t make it sound like I ignored you for eighteen months.”

“The payments,” the tablet answered.

I looked at Leah’s list.

“One payment every month. This isn’t a single charge accidentally printed twice.”

“You paid this company every month?”

“That’s how regular services work.”

“Without checking whether Nora got a ride?”

“I did check.”

“With whom?”

“People who understand these arrangements.”

“Give us their names.”

Paul pulled the folder closer.

“We can verify the paperwork.”

“Then let’s verify it,” I said.

Dana put her hand across the cover.

“Not that.”

“What’s in it?” I asked.

“Other paperwork. Things that don’t concern Nora.”

“Then leave those aside.”

“I can’t empty my whole filing system here.”

“Nobody asked you to.”

Paul moved his hands back.

“If there are unrelated records, we don’t need them.”

“Exactly,” Dana said.

Nora’s tablet spoke.

“I want the Briar records.”

“The invoices?”

“And what they paid for.”

“That’s already on them.”

“A service period isn’t a ride,” I said.

“Then what would satisfy you?”

“A booking. A driver. Something that happened.”

Dana’s voice sharpened.

“You’re calling me a liar.”

“I’m asking for evidence.”

Leah held her pen.

Nora opened her notes.

“I asked for the agreement,” her tablet read.

“When?” I asked.

“Before I called the bank.”

Dana leaned toward her.

“I said I’d find it.”

“Did you?”

“It isn’t something I keep on my phone.”

“Where do you keep it?”

“At home.”

“Which file?”

“I’d need to look.”

Paul spoke softly.

“Then we’ll look.”

Nora’s tablet answered.

“Did I ever see it?”

Dana stared at her.

“You saw plenty of paperwork.”

“This agreement,” the tablet said.

“I don’t remember every document.”

“Do you remember a driver?”

“Beth, stop.”

“Do you remember a vehicle?”

Dana looked away.

“There must be a record somewhere,” Paul said.

“That’s what I’m asking for.”

Dana lifted her chin.

“I’ve spent two years making sure she has what she needs.”

“Then the records should show that.”

“They do.”

Nora’s tablet spoke.

“Show me one.”

Dana opened her phone.

A pharmacy receipt appeared.

“This,” she said.

Nora shook her head.

“The Briar payments,” the tablet said.

“I can’t pull up everything instantly.”

“You found that one.”

“It’s easier.”

“What makes the other one harder?”

Dana pressed the screen dark.

“You’re determined to see something wrong.”

I looked at Nora’s empty glass.

“Eighteen payments.”

Dana put her phone beside the invoice.

“What do you want from me?”

Nora typed slowly.

Nobody filled the silence for her.

Her tablet spoke.

“To know what happened to my money.”

Dana’s eyes shone.

“I took care of you.”

“I know,” the tablet answered.

“When you couldn’t do things yourself.”

“I know.”

“And now you’re treating me like a stranger.”

Nora’s left hand rested against the authorization.

I waited.

“I’m treating it like my money,” her tablet said.

Paul looked at me.

“Beth, can we lower the temperature?”

“By answering her.”

Dana pulled the folder toward herself.

“All right.”

“If you want the paperwork, I’ll show you the paperwork,” Dana said.

Paul’s hand settled beside the folder.

“Only what concerns Nora.”

“That’s what this is.”

Leah put her phone down.

Dana opened a pocket behind the invoices.

A smaller receipt lay inside.

Nora’s tablet asked, “What is that?”

“Something that will explain the payments.”

“From Briar?” I asked.

“It shows where the money was credited.”

“A service record?”

“A payment record.”

“We already have bank records.”

“This is different.”

Dana unfolded it once.

“Then show Nora,” I said.

My sister kept hold of the lower edge.

“Let her read.”

Nora held out her hand.

Dana passed the receipt across.

“Read all of it,” my sister said.

“I will,” Nora’s tablet answered.

Paul leaned toward the page.

“We should make sure we understand what it covers.”

Nora moved the paper into the center.

“Can you read with me?” her tablet asked.

“Yes.”

Dana nodded.

“Then you’ll see.”

I followed Nora’s finger down the printed lines.

The date matched a payment.

The amount matched, too.

Then her finger stopped.

“Here,” the tablet said.

I leaned closer.

Under “Purpose of Payment,” the receipt did not say transport. It said, “Business loan installment.”