Chapter 6: The Man Beside Me

“Until I’m retired.”
I read it again.
Paul’s chair leg scraped the kitchen floor.
“Beth.”
“Was that you?”
“You’re looking at one sentence.”
“Was it yours?”
Nora turned the tablet toward him.
Her left hand stayed on its edge.
“Answer,” she said.
He looked at me instead.
For twenty-eight years, that look had meant something needed fixing, and we would fix it together.
Now he was waiting for me to help him around her question.
My phone rang beside the untouched coffee.
Aaron’s name appeared.
Paul reached toward it.
I picked it up first.
“Nora,” I said. “It’s your lawyer.”
“Would you like speakerphone?”
Her tablet answered, “Yes. Here.”
I set the phone beside her.
Aaron spoke after I identified myself.
“Nora, is Beth with you?”
“Yes,” her tablet said.
“Anyone else?”
“My uncle,” she typed.
Paul folded his arms.
“I’m the person being discussed.”
“Nora, do you want to review these documents privately?”
She looked at him, then typed.
“Read them here. He can hear.”
“The lender has completed its review of what it can release. I have the borrower documents and related correspondence.”
“Whose documents?” I asked.
Aaron paused.
“The guarantor named in the agreement is Paul Reed.”
Paul didn’t move.
The refrigerator hummed behind him.
“Could there be another Paul Reed?” I asked.
I hated the question before Aaron answered it.
“Beth, the address matches yours. The identifying information matches the records Wesley supplied. Nora, I’ve sent you the documents.”
“Open them,” her tablet said.
The attachment loaded beneath her finger.
There was our address.
There was my husband’s signature.
“Briar Household Services,” I read.
“The borrower,” Aaron said.
“And Paul?”
“The guarantor. These records also identify him as the business owner who gave the repayment instructions.”
Paul finally lowered his arms.
“I can explain that.”
“Nora, scroll to the correspondence,” Aaron said.
She did.
“Is an account name enough to prove who sent something?” I asked.
“No. We have more than that. There’s a signed borrowing agreement, ownership information, and correspondence arranging the payment schedule.”
“Which correspondence?”
“The instructions from Paul’s business account. Wesley’s replies address him by name. Paul also acknowledged the outstanding balance.”
Paul leaned toward the screen.
“I never said I didn’t have a business.”
“You said Dana’s investment,” I said.
“That was what she called it.”
Nora typed without looking up.
Her tablet said, “And what did you call it?”
“A vehicle detailing venture,” Aaron said.
“Private,” I added.
“Yes. Separate from his municipal employment.”
Paul pulled out a chair.
“We tried to get it going. There were equipment costs. A lease. Financing. It didn’t work.”
“We?” I asked.
“Dana helped with the books.”
“Did you tell me?”
“I told you I was looking into something.”
“You told me you were pricing a pressure washer.”
“That was part of it.”
Nora tapped the agreement.
Her tablet asked, “How much?”
Aaron answered.
“The scheduled repayment obligation, including financing costs, was eighty-seven thousand dollars.”
Paul looked down.
My kitchen seemed to tilt sideways.
“Eighty-seven thousand,” I repeated.
“It wasn’t all borrowed cash,” Paul said.
“Aaron just said that.”
“The costs piled up.”
“And my money?” Nora’s tablet asked.
Paul looked at her then.
“Some of the payments came from your account.”
“Eighteen,” she typed.
“I know.”
“Say how much.”
“Forty-eight thousand, six hundred.”
“Did you tell my mother to send it?”
His fingers closed around the chair back.
“Yes.”
Nothing fell.
No glass broke.
The room stayed exactly where it had been.
I wished something would move so I could understand why I couldn’t.
Nora’s tablet asked, “Did you tell her to call it transportation?”
“Yes,” he said.
I stood.
The chair struck the cabinet behind me.
“You watched us look for a driver who didn’t exist.”
“Beth, sit down.”
“You watched Nora prove she’d missed therapy.”
“I was trying to keep things calm.”
“For whom?”
“For everyone.”
“You let Dana tell that room the program was closed.”
“I didn’t know she was going to say that.”
“But you knew why the tuition wasn’t paid.”
“Yes.”
Nora slid her own tablet into the space between us.
Its voice stayed level.
“Stop talking about what she said. Tell me what you told her to do.”
“Dana came to me about the money,” Paul said.
“Which money?” I asked.
“The inheritance. She was handling expenses already.”
Aaron interrupted.
“Paul, Nora’s authorization did not permit financing your business.”
“I understand that now.”
“Did you understand it then?”
“I knew we needed time.”
Nora typed.
“Who needed time?”
“The family.”
“My father left that money to me.”
“Nora, I know.”
“You used it while I was learning how to speak again.”
Paul’s mouth opened, then closed.
I watched her choose the words.
She didn’t hurry because he was uncomfortable.
Her tablet said, “You had words. You didn’t ask.”
“I thought we could replace it before you needed it,” he said.
“She needed it,” I said.
“The transport bills were there to keep the account simple.”
“Simple for her?”
“For Dana.”
“So Nora would see a service instead of your debt.”
He rubbed his forehead.
“That sounds worse than it was.”
“How?”
“We weren’t spending it on vacations. There was a business obligation. There were consequences if I couldn’t pay.”
Nora’s tablet answered.
“There were consequences when I couldn’t pay, too.”
I saw the kitchen chair again.
Her cane behind dirty dishes.
My husband standing beside me, offering to help.
“You said you handled the paperwork,” I said.
“I did.”
“Not just organizing bills.”
“No.”
“You made the bills.”
“Dana prepared the invoices.”
“At your direction?”
“Yes.”
“And when I asked about them?”
“I wanted us to get through the dinner.”
“Your dinner.”
“Our daughter worked hard on it.”
“Don’t put Leah between you and this.”
Paul glanced at my phone.
“Do we have to do everything with a lawyer listening?”
Nora typed, then pressed the speech button.
“Yes.”
Aaron waited quietly.
I stayed standing.
For once, Paul couldn’t turn the next question into a plan for all of us.
“When did you bring Dana into this?” I asked.
“After the business failed.”
“Before the first payment?”
“Yes.”
“Did she believe you would put the money back?”
“I told her I would.”
Nora’s tablet asked, “Did you tell her to lie when I asked about the rides?”
“I told her we couldn’t have everything falling apart before retirement.”
“That email,” I said.
He nodded.
“You wrote it.”
“Yes.”
I wanted him to deny one thing.
Just one.
Instead, every answer fitted into the space he had made around our lives.
“Did Dana choose to send those payments?” I asked.
“She did.”
“Then she knew,” I said.
“She knew it was temporary.”
“Did she know Nora hadn’t agreed?”
Paul looked toward the door Dana had used.
“Yes.”
Nora let the answer sit there.
Her tablet spoke.
“She can answer for herself. You can answer for yourself.”
“Nora, neither of us wanted to hurt you.”
“You wanted my money.”
“We needed help.”
“You wanted my money without having to hear no.”
He lowered himself into the chair.
I had seen that posture after long shifts, after funerals, after bad news.
I had always brought him something.
This time, I kept my hands empty.
“I’m retiring Friday,” Paul said.
“We know,” I said.
“There’s a payout. I was going to finish this.”
“Finish whose debt?”
“The situation.”
Aaron spoke.
“Nora, there’s a repayment schedule in the lender’s packet. Would you like to review it?”
“Yes,” her tablet answered.
She opened the next attachment.
Paul stood halfway.
“Those are arrangements with the lender.”
“Then sit,” I said.
He sat.
Aaron directed Nora to the final entry.
The remaining scheduled balance was thirty-eight thousand, four hundred dollars.
Beside it was Friday’s due date.
“Your retirement payout was meant for that,” I said.
“It would settle things.”
“With the lender,” I said.
“Yes.”
“And Nora?”
“I would work something out.”
“Where is that written?”
“It didn’t need to be written between family.”
Nora turned the tablet toward herself.
Her voice asked, “Where is my repayment on this schedule?”
Paul leaned forward.
“That schedule is for the business loan.”
“That is where my money went.”
Aaron answered.
“These documents contain no arrangement to reimburse Nora. I’m not saying no other document could exist. I’m saying there isn’t one here.”
“Is there another?” I asked Paul.
“I planned to take care of her.”
Nora’s tablet said, “I am already here.”
I put both palms on the table.
“You called this family survival.”
“That’s what it was.”
“Your business survived as a bill. Nora lost rides, tuition, and the right to know why.”
“We still had a house. We still had expenses.”
“Did her money pay our mortgage?”
“No. It went to the lender.”
“Then say that.”
“I’ve said it.”
“You keep saying family.”
His eyes lifted to mine.
“I was trying to protect you.”
I remembered how easily I had let him stand between Dana and me.
The protection had faced the wrong direction.
“Move your chair back,” I said.
“What?”
“You’re blocking Nora’s way out.”
Paul looked down at his chair.
He moved it.
Nora picked up her cane but didn’t stand.
Her tablet said, “I’m not leaving yet.”
Aaron asked, “Nora, do you want to continue discussing this with your uncle present, or take the next steps privately?”
She typed.
“Privately.”
“I can go into the other room,” Paul said.
“Please go outside,” I said.
“This is my house, too.”
“And she is allowed a private conversation.”
He took his keys from the counter.
“Don’t make decisions you can’t undo.”
Nora’s tablet answered, “You already made mine without asking.”
The back door closed.
I waited until his footsteps left the porch.
“Are you all right to continue?” Aaron asked Nora.
Her tablet said, “Yes. I want my mother’s access stopped.”
“We discussed that this afternoon. Have you got the account documents?”
She opened her saved folder.
I reached for my phone, then stopped.
“Should I tell Paul we’re doing this?”
Nora looked at me.
The question sounded different once it left my mouth.
“No,” I said. “I don’t need to.”
Aaron spoke.
“Nora is the client. Share information only as she directs.”
Her tablet said, “Keep this with us.”
* * *
We moved to the living room.
Nora chose the armchair by the window.
I brought the charger she requested.
“Would you like me to sit beside you?”
Her tablet answered, “Across from me.”
I sat.
Aaron helped her prepare the revocation and explained the bank’s process.
“You can give Beth permission to assist without giving her authority over your money.”
“That,” her tablet said.
“I can help with the call,” I said.
“You can wait,” Nora answered.
I folded my hands.
She found the bank’s number herself.
When the representative answered, Nora’s tablet spoke.
“I need to remove an authorized person.”
The representative waited through Nora’s typed answers.
She didn’t ask me to speak instead.
“Are you requesting removal of Dana Mercer’s authority?”
Nora’s tablet answered, “Yes. Effective now.”
“We’ll send the required confirmation through your banking messages.”
“Aaron helped me prepare a revocation,” Nora typed.
“You can submit that there, too.”
“Will she be able to make another payment?”
“Once this restriction is applied, she won’t be able to initiate transactions under that authorization.”
“And saved payments?”
“We’ll review those with you now.”
Nora lifted one finger toward me.
Wait.
I nodded.
For once, silence was something I could give.
We checked the account together at Nora’s request.
No new transfer had appeared.
The bank confirmed the restriction and sent its reference number.
Nora saved it with the revocation.
“Will this get my money back?” her tablet asked Aaron.
“No. It helps protect what remains. Recovering the transferred money is a separate matter.”
“I want both.”
“We’ll pursue both.”
“Will you send my mother notice?”
“Yes. We’ll document delivery.”
“Today.”
“Today.”
I hadn’t realized I was pressing my nails into my palms.
Nora unplugged the charger.
Her tablet asked me, “Can I stay here tonight if he stays somewhere else?”
“Yes,” I said.
“Can you make that happen?”
“I can ask him to leave tonight. If he refuses, we’ll choose somewhere you feel safe.”
Nora considered that.
“I don’t want another argument.”
“Neither do I.”
Aaron said, “You don’t have to settle your living arrangements or every family question during this call.”
“What do I have to settle?” I asked.
“What Nora wants you to do with the information you have.”
Her tablet answered before I could.
“Save it. Don’t send him anything.”
“I won’t.”
I saved the messages in my own account, then signed out of our shared computer.
* * *
After Aaron ended the call, I stood by the window.
Paul waited beside his car, phone in hand.
“Do you want him back inside?” I asked.
Nora typed.
“I want him to answer one more question.”
“Which one?”
“I will ask him.”
I opened the door.
“Nora wants to speak to you.”
“Did you lock Dana out of the account?”
“That conversation was private.”
“She’ll need money for Nora’s expenses.”
“Nora will pay her expenses.”
“What did Aaron tell you?”
I held the door without answering.
For years, I had told Paul everything first.
Now I let him wait there.
He came into the living room.
Nora stayed in the armchair.
I sat across from her again.
Paul remained standing.
Her tablet asked, “Why didn’t you ask me?”
“Because you were recovering.”
“I was still me.”
“I know that.”
“You acted like I wouldn’t notice.”
“I thought we could put it back before this became a problem.”
“It became a problem when you took it.”
He looked at me.
“Beth, I need you to understand something.”
“Tell Nora.”
“She didn’t give you permission,” I added.
Paul straightened.
“I have something that says she did.”
Nora’s fingers stopped above the tablet’s keys.
“What something?” I asked.
“An agreement.”
Nora’s tablet said, “Show me.”
Paul took his phone out.
“Dana has the paperwork. I have a copy.”
“Then show the copy,” I said.
“Will you actually look at it?”
“Yes.”
“Without deciding it’s wrong before you’ve read it?”
“I will look at it.”
He opened a file and held the phone toward me.
Nora lifted her left hand.
“Me,” she said.
He shifted the screen toward her.
She leaned forward, then sat back.
Her tablet spoke.
“I need it bigger.”
“Can I send it to you?”
“Yes. The whole document,” her tablet answered clearly.
The file arrived.
Nora opened it and enlarged the first page.
I read only when she angled the tablet toward me.
“Family loan agreement,” I said.
“Forty-eight thousand, six hundred dollars.”
Paul nodded once.
“It records what we agreed.”
Nora’s tablet asked, “When did I agree?”
“The agreement has a date.”
“That wasn’t my question.”
“You signed it.”
The paragraph described advances for the business and called them voluntary.
Her money had become generosity in a sentence.
“Where is the repayment date?” I asked.
“We left that flexible.”
“Did you?”
“Beth, please read the signature before you say anything else.”
Nora scrolled down.
There was her name beneath a signature.
Paul stepped closer.
“Look carefully. I’m not asking you to trust my memory.”
I put out my hand.
“Give her room.”
“That’s her signature.”
“Let her answer.”
Nora touched the screen, enlarging the loops and the uneven final stroke.
Her face changed.
Not confusion.
Recognition.
My stomach tightened.
“Do you know it?” I asked.
She nodded once.
Paul let out a breath.
“Then we can stop calling this something it wasn’t.”
Nora looked at the page and typed, “That was my signature. But I signed it for something else.”