Chapter 10: The Sound We Chose

A father just home from work stares at two white sheets hanging in the laundry room while his wife holds a label maker and films him and his brother watches from the hallway

“A short visit,” I read aloud. “With Cora beside me the whole time. June doesn’t have to come.”

His name was beneath the words.

I put the page back in its envelope.

Micah was still building his bridge.

“Did you read it?” he asked.

“Yes,” I told him.

He pressed a craft stick into place.

“Are you mad?” he asked.

“No,” I replied.

“Cora said the adults would look at it,” Micah said.

“They will,” I told him. “We’ll talk about a safe plan. You don’t have to arrange it yourself.”

Micah looked toward the front room.

“June doesn’t want to,” he said.

“She can make her own choice,” I replied.

“And I can ask?” Micah said.

“Yes,” I told him.

“What if I want to leave before it’s over?” Micah asked.

“You tell Cora, and she helps you leave,” I said.

“Even if Mom’s talking?” he asked.

“Yes,” I told him. “You can stop a visit while someone is talking.”

Micah held the bridge upright.

“Will you still pick me up?” he asked.

“I’ll be waiting where the adults arrange,” I said.

“I don’t want to stay there,” Micah said.

“I understand,” I replied. “You asked for a visit. You didn’t ask to move.”

Micah looked at the envelope.

“Can you keep that?” he asked.

“Yes,” I told him. “You’ve told us what you want. We’ll carry the papers.”

I stayed beside the table until the glue held.

* * *

The following morning, June waited until Micah went to brush his teeth.

“Do I have to go because he does?” she asked.

“No,” I told her.

June pulled her sleeve over her hand.

“Do I have to help him decide?” she asked.

“The adults will help him,” I replied.

“What if he’s sad afterward?” June asked.

“We’ll take care of him,” I said. “You can be his sister.”

Then she picked up her school bag.

“Can you check whether my lunch is in here?” she asked.

I waited for her to open the zipper.

Then I checked.

* * *

Several weeks later, the coordinator called Cora and me to confirm Micah’s first visit.

“The facility has approved a brief visit,” the coordinator said. “Staff will supervise, and Cora will remain beside him throughout.”

“Who explains the ending to Celeste?” Cora asked.

“We do,” the coordinator replied. “Micah doesn’t have to persuade her to let him go.”

“And if he changes his mind before we arrive?” I asked.

“Call us,” the coordinator said. “We’ll cancel. We’ll review how he does afterward before arranging anything further.”

Cora took the pen from my hand.

“I’ll write down the pickup place,” she said. “You stay with June.”

* * *

On the morning of the visit, June stayed home with me.

We made pancakes.

She turned the first one before it was ready.

It folded against the spatula.

“I can make another,” June said.

“We have enough batter,” I told her.

June looked at the folded pancake.

“Could that one be mine?” she asked.

“Yes,” I said.

We ate before Cora called.

“The visit ended on time,” Cora told me. “Micah’s with me.”

“How is he?” I asked.

“He wants to tell you himself,” Cora replied.

Micah took the phone.

“Mom looked different,” he said.

I stayed at the kitchen table.

“Do you want to talk now or when you get home?” I asked.

“When I get home,” Micah replied.

“All right,” I said.

“And can I sit with you?” he asked.

“Yes,” I told him.

That afternoon, when they returned, Micah sat beside me without taking off his jacket.

“Can I miss her and want to come back here?” he asked.

“Yes,” I replied.

Micah leaned against my arm.

June carried her plate to the sink.

“There are pancakes left,” June told Micah.

“Can I have one later?” he asked.

“I’ll put yours in the refrigerator,” June said.

She reached for a plate.

I loosened Micah’s jacket zipper only after he nodded.

* * *

Two years after I came home early, June sat at our kitchen table with an unfinished school poster.

She was ten.

A line of lettering slanted toward the bottom corner.

June covered it with her arm when I approached.

“Do you want help?” I asked.

“I can fix it,” she replied.

I stopped beside the chair.

“Okay,” I said.

June reached for another sheet.

It was the fourth.

“Would you like me to hold the ruler?” I asked.

“You’ll see it,” she said.

“The crooked line?” I asked.

June nodded.

“I can see it already,” I told her.

She pulled the new paper closer.

“Are you upset?” June asked.

“No,” I said.

June watched my hand near the ruler.

“Then why are you standing there?” she asked.

I stepped back.

“You’re right,” I told her. “I offered help, and you haven’t asked for it.”

I sat across the table.

June worked for another minute.

Then she pushed the ruler toward me.

“Hold this part?” she asked.

I held it where she pointed.

“Does it have to be straight?” June asked.

“What did your teacher ask for?” I said.

“For us to show what we learned,” June replied.

“Can someone read what you learned?” I asked.

June lifted her arm from the crooked line.

“Yes,” she said.

“Then you can decide whether it needs another sheet,” I told her.

June put the unused paper back.

The following week, June started another assignment three times.

At dinner, she watched me mark our calendar.

“Do you still work with Uncle Russell?” she asked.

“No,” I replied. “I sold my part of the business. These are jobs here in town.”

“Every job?” June asked.

“Every job I’ve accepted,” I said. “If the plan changes, I’ll tell you.”

Micah pointed at Friday.

“Is that Cora?” he asked.

“Yes,” I said. “She’s coming while I finish a repair.”

“Can we call?” June asked.

“You can call,” I told her. “You can ask what’s happening even when I’ve already written it down.”

June returned to her unfinished assignment.

I left the calendar where she could reach it.

* * *

Three years after the discovery, I came home late from a repair that had run past its scheduled time.

I had called Cora and sent the children an updated arrival time.

Micah still waited beside the front door.

He was eight.

June was eleven and doing homework at the table.

“Why didn’t you come when you said?” Micah asked.

“The repair took longer,” I replied. “I sent the new time.”

“I saw,” he said.

I put my bag down.

“You still needed me here,” I said.

Micah nodded.

Cora stood in the kitchen doorway.

“He wanted to wait,” she told me.

“Can we sit down?” I asked Micah.

He followed me to the couch.

“Was the new time wrong too?” Micah asked.

“By twelve minutes,” I replied.

“I watched the clock,” he said.

Twelve minutes had felt ordinary to me.

They hadn’t to him.

“I’m sorry I didn’t update you again,” I told him.

Micah leaned against the couch.

“Can you put your bag away after?” he asked.

“After we sit,” I said.

* * *

Later that year, after another supervised visit, Micah asked to pause the next one.

Cora placed the visit folder on our kitchen counter.

“Did something happen?” I asked.

“I’m tired after,” Micah said.

“We’ll tell the people coordinating it,” I replied.

“Will Mom be mad?” he asked.

“The adults will speak with her,” I told him.

“Do I have to explain?” Micah asked.

“You can tell them what you want them to know,” I said. “You don’t have to manage her reaction.”

“Can I still ask again later?” Micah asked.

“Yes,” I told him.

“What if I don’t ask?” he said.

“Then you don’t ask,” I replied.

He pushed the folder toward Cora.

Three months passed before he asked again.

June did not attend.

* * *

That same year, a letter from Russell arrived through his attorney.

He had completed his custodial sentence.

The restrictions concerning the children remained.

In Nina’s office, I read one paragraph aloud.

“‘I knew more than I admitted. I helped keep you away. I want a chance to tell the children I’m sorry,’” I read.

Nina waited while I reached the last page.

“What do you want to do?” she asked.

“Keep the letter with the record,” I replied.

“And the request?” Nina asked.

“No access,” I said.

Nina nodded.

“Does it feel different now that he’s apologized?” she asked.

“He named what he did,” I replied. “That matters. It doesn’t make a meeting right for them.”

“Does he know that an apology doesn’t change the restriction?” I asked.

“I’ll put that in the response,” Nina said.

“He’ll say I’m holding on to it,” I told her.

“Do you want to answer that?” Nina asked.

“No,” I replied. “I want the children to have a Saturday that doesn’t involve his request.”

I handed the letter back.

Nina placed it in the folder.

* * *

Five years after the discovery, Celeste completed her four-year custodial sentence.

June was thirteen.

Micah was ten.

At the contact-review meeting, Celeste sat across from Cora and me.

“Your release doesn’t change these conditions,” the coordinator told Celeste, opening the plan. “We’re here to discuss supervised visits outside the facility. No other access has been approved.”

“I understand,” Celeste replied.

Celeste wore no bracelet.

“I put them behind the sheets,” Celeste said. “I used the sound to control what they did.”

I kept my hands on the table.

“I copied your initials,” Celeste continued. “I told them you approved when you hadn’t.”

The coordinator let her finish.

“I made them afraid to tell you,” Celeste said.

For the first time, she named the actions without calling them practice.

I had once filled her silences with excuses.

I left this one empty.

“What are you asking for?” I said.

“The visits allowed under the plan,” Celeste replied.

“With supervision,” the coordinator said.

“Yes,” Celeste replied.

“And June’s position?” the coordinator asked.

Celeste looked at me.

“I hoped Ethan could explain that I’ve changed,” she said.

“I can explain the arrangements,” I replied. “I won’t ask June to make you feel better.”

Celeste looked down.

“I want her to know I’m sorry,” she said.

“A letter can be reviewed through the existing process,” the coordinator told her. “Reading or answering it won’t be a condition.”

Celeste nodded.

“Will you tell June I accepted this?” Celeste asked.

“I’ll answer if she asks,” I said.

Celeste looked toward the coordinator.

“It’s in the notes,” the coordinator told her. “Acceptance of the conditions is required. It isn’t a message the children have to receive.”

The plan remained.

“The visits will stay brief and supervised,” the coordinator said. “We’ll review them. There will be no unannounced pickups or private calls.”

Celeste touched the corner of the plan.

“Can I send June something through Micah?” Celeste asked.

“No,” the coordinator replied. “He won’t carry messages. Use the review process.”

Celeste moved her hand away from the paper.

* * *

A month later, Cora brought the visit folder to our table.

“Celeste asked Micah about June,” Cora told me. “The monitor reminded her that Micah wasn’t there to report on his sister. She stopped when she was reminded.”

“Did Micah have to answer?” I asked.

“No,” Cora replied.

“Did Celeste ask you to bring him back sooner?” I asked.

“She asked the coordinator,” Cora replied. “The schedule stayed the same.”

“Good,” I said.

“I told Micah what happened,” Cora added. “I didn’t want him thinking she’d handed me an instruction I had to follow.”

* * *

Six years after the discovery, June left a reviewed letter from Celeste unopened on the kitchen counter.

Micah came home from a supervised visit carrying a small paper drawing.

Cora stayed for dinner.

“Did you want that in your room?” I asked June, indicating the envelope.

“Not today,” June said.

“I can keep it where you choose,” I told her.

“The drawer,” June replied.

I put it in the drawer.

Micah laid his drawing beside his plate.

“Mom asked about my science project,” he said.

June looked at the drawing.

“What did you tell her?” she asked.

“About the bridge,” Micah replied.

June nodded.

“Did she like it?” she asked.

“Yes,” Micah said.

June returned to setting the table.

“I don’t want that next to my plate,” June told Micah.

Micah moved the drawing to his other side.

“Here?” he asked.

“That’s fine,” June replied.

Cora passed the bread.

After dinner that evening, Micah told Cora he didn’t want the next scheduled visit.

“Do you want me to tell the coordinator?” Cora asked.

“Yes,” he said.

“Anything you want included?” Cora asked.

“Just that I want a break,” Micah replied.

Cora wrote it down.

June looked at me.

“Do you think I’ll ever want to go?” she asked.

“I don’t know,” I told her.

“Is that okay?” June asked.

“Yes,” I replied.

I closed the drawer only after she moved her fingers away from it.

* * *

Seven years after I came home early, June was fifteen and Micah was twelve.

That spring, I was helping Micah clamp the sides of a model bridge in our community art room.

The blue house lay beside his supplies, paint worn off one corner.

June came over.

“I want to use the gray machine next time,” she said. “The label maker on the shelf. The one they keep for open studio.”

Gray casing.

Black tape.

A different machine.

“The one with black tape?” I asked.

“Yes,” June replied.

“Do you want someone beside you?” I asked.

“You,” she said. “But don’t take it unless I ask.”

“Okay,” I told her.

“I talked to Dr. Vega about it,” June said. “She asked whose idea it was.”

“What did you tell her?” I asked.

“Mine,” June replied. “I want labels for the shared drawers. People keep taking my pencils.”

“Would you like me to ask about another tool?” I asked.

“I know where the stickers are,” June said. “I might use them. I want to decide there.”

I nodded.

“And if you want to stop on Saturday?” I asked.

“Then I stop,” June said. “If I want to leave Saturday, that doesn’t cancel what I’m asking now.”

“It doesn’t,” I agreed.

“If I stop, don’t finish it for me,” June said.

“I’ll leave it where you choose,” I told her.

* * *

The next Saturday, the art room’s windows were open.

Cora sorted paintbrushes at one end of the table.

Ms. Brooks, who supervised the studio, placed the gray label maker on a mat.

“No deadline,” Ms. Brooks told June. “The adhesive labels are here too, if you want those instead.”

“I want this one,” June replied.

Ms. Brooks stepped back.

Micah set his model bridge on the lower shelf.

Then he took the blue house from his pocket.

“Here?” he asked June.

June looked at the shelf beside his supplies.

“Sure,” she said.

Micah put it there.

He returned to the bridge with both hands empty.

June turned the letter wheel.

I stood beside her.

“Can you move the mat?” she asked.

“Which way?” I asked.

“Closer,” June replied.

I moved it.

She pressed the handle.

One click.

Her hand stopped.

I stayed where I was.

“I want a minute,” June said.

“All right,” I replied.

She put the tool down.

Cora continued sorting the brushes.

Micah asked Ms. Brooks for glue.

The room kept moving around us.

June looked at me.

“Don’t tell me I did well yet,” she said.

“I won’t,” I replied.

“I might still use the stickers,” June said.

“They’re there,” I told her.

June stood quietly.

Then she picked up the tool again.

She worked through the letters, turned the wheel for a space, and continued.

When she reached the cutter, she paused once more.

“Stay?” June asked me.

“I’m here,” I replied.

She pressed it.

The strip came free.

ASK FIRST.

Ms. Brooks opened the shared supply drawer.

“Would you like it here?” she asked June.

June nodded.

She pressed the label onto the drawer front herself.

Micah lifted his bridge.

“Can somebody hold this side?” he asked.

Cora reached toward it.

“This side?” Cora asked.

Micah pointed.

“That one,” he said.

June looked at the label maker.

“I want another label,” she said.

“For what?” Ms. Brooks asked.

“My sketchbook,” June replied.

I moved my coffee away from her elbow.

June glanced at me.

“You can sit down, Dad,” she said.

I took the chair beside the table.

The blue house remained on the shelf.

Micah adjusted his bridge while Cora held the side he had chosen.

June turned the wheel to the first letter of her name.

I watched her hand settle on the handle.

The label maker clicked, and this time neither child disappeared.

The End.